Why Affiliate Marketing standards matter

The next few weeks will answer a fundamental question for me – whether I’ve succeeded or failed in one of the main missions for the APMA.

Will the newly launched Subnetwork Code of Conduct, designed to stamp out creeping bad practice land? Will industry coalesce behind it and view it as a de facto Gold Standard that they will base their commercial decisions around?

There’s no guarantee, but there is successful precedence in the UK.

I’ve always believed industry should collaborate to make things better. Competitors should want to work together. Why? Because our industry is small and niche. Bad decisions could wipe out swathes of our channel overnight, and we need to give decision-makers no excuses or ammunition that make that option easy or acceptable.

Self-regulation is self-protection

Put simply, mature industries self-regulate. Consider a lawmaker or rule enforcer whose attention turns to elements of the affiliate channel. If we can show that we’re fully aware of the issue but, more than that, we’ve created our own commonly agreed goals and standards, don’t you think they will see us as a credible body they can work with?

The UK affiliate marketing channel has some, albeit patchy, heritage of implementing standards.

Scroll back more than 15 years ago and all the major affiliate networks in the UK had agreed to clean up the voucher space. It was a mess. Cookies dropped left, right and centre in a true race to the bottom.

Advertisers were, rightfully, questioning what exactly they were paying for. It’s no coincidence that this ushered in the age of words like ‘cannibalisation’ and ‘incrementality’ (still not a word) finding a comfortable place in the everyday affiliate conversation.

The Code of Conduct for vouchers we’d signed off wasn’t perfect. But it was better than anything we had and it also was a universal standard. Networks could go above and beyond if they wanted to, but it offered assurances to brands that the network they used was committed to doing better. And more than that, it actually provided protection for networks in any potential commercial disputes with individual partners; “don’t blame me, blame the rules”.

At the time I was chair of the now defunct Affiliate Marketing Council which meant responsibility for dealing with breaches landed squarely with me. A few weeks before peak trading we recognised that we needed to remove a major voucher affiliate for two weeks during because they continued to breach the Code of Conduct.

What happened? All networks acted on it. Yes, there was a direct commercial hit, but the principle outweighed a few grubby pounds of profit.

Unintended consequences

There are additional consequences to widely recognised Codes of Conduct.

For new actors, they provide something akin to a template for how to ethically build their businesses. They also force existing players to professionalise and stop exploiting the grey areas, lack of prescription, gaps in compliance monitoring and loopholes that inevitably exist in an industry comprised of tens of thousands of active businesses.

There was an additional unintended consequence. Some companies decided to build above and beyond the Code. Why do the bare minimum when you can create an even shinier Gold Standard? Guess what, brands love that.

From my side of the fence it proved something important: collective action can work, even when it requires businesses to make difficult commercial decisions.

Fast forward a few years and another set of standards launched, this time dealing with browser extensions and toolbars. Did you wonder why the furore around Honey and others didn’t really register in the UK as a major issue? Can I introduce you to the Code of Conduct that nipped many of these issues in the bud from the outset.

Subnetwork Code of Conduct

Last week I announced the launch of the APMA’s first Code of Conduct that has the potential to fundamentally improve standards in our industry. The Subnetwork Code of Conduct was created in response to various factors: brands and agencies signalled it as their number one compliance issue (67% of brands and 76% of agencies); a flood of traffic from overseas was overwhelming programmes; legitimate affiliates’ cookies are being overwritten; reputationally, it’s a dreadful look for our industry; many subnetworks are opaque backchannels, allowing nefarious players to circumvent the rules.

Some absolutely aren’t, and subnetworks have been instrumental in bringing brilliant publishers into the affiliate fold. But they’ll be ok. Because they’re the types of businesses that brands will flock to. Again, a standard is nothing to be feared by ethical businesses who abide by the rules.

The Code establishes common requirements around publisher identification, traffic transparency, attribution, programme restrictions and compliance. Subnetworks seeking accreditation must verify their own practices, formally accept responsibility for compliance and agree to potential checks and audits.

Last week I emailed all APMA member networks and agencies, asking them to officially recognise the Code, embed it in their working practices and point brands to the signatories so they can make their own business choices.

We’re not asking networks and agencies to become accredited themselves. We’re asking them to recognise the standard and make it part of how they assess and recommend subnetwork partners.

Whole industry advocacy

But it needs greater advocacy across the entire affiliate ecosystem. If two-thirds of brands cite subnetworks as an industry concern, it’s success also relies on every advertiser challenging their agency and network suppliers to ensure they support it. Why stop there? It’s also in a publisher’s interest to push for its adoption if their sales are being overwritten.

It’s a Code that has teeth but ultimately relies on industry support to make it bite.

The APMA is not a legislative body; we can’t issue sanctions. But we can create checks and balances and awareness. We can create clear signposting for brands who have been burned by the worst excesses of affiliate marketing.

We can also make accreditation status visible, giving advertisers a clearer basis on which to question, assess and select their partners. So what will success look like? If, by launch on December 1st, the majority of APMA member agencies and networks haven’t thrown their weight behind the Code, it may be back to the drawing board. Perhaps I reassess the APMA’s purpose for 2027.

I’m not naive. When the voucher code of conduct was released, the industry was expanding at a very healthy double-digit rate. Growth is tougher to come by in 2026, and browser settings, cookie banners, and AI are all chipping away at the channel’s ability to remain viable. But I’m still not convinced that we just leave it for the market to decide what’s right or wrong. Many brands do not invest enough resources to be across the day-to-day details of their programmes and need shortcuts to empower them to make better decisions.

Besides, the market has decided. We’re an industry that drives 10% of UK e-commerce revenue but accounts for just 5% of digital marketing investment.

Doing this stuff isn’t easy; it’s complex, messy and imperfect. But I’ve always felt that doing nothing is worse.

So my challenge to brands, agencies, publishers and networks is clear: let’s never hear another panel at another event have any ammunition to claim our channel is reputationally tarnished. Now is the time to throw your weight behind this and future Codes of Conduct; let the only losers be the ones who try to damage our industry.

Read about the new Subnetwork Publisher Code of Conduct here.

Menu
together we grow - the APMA